Ciarb Australia Essay Competition

Ciarb Essay Competition

Entries for the 2026 Chartered Institute of Arbitrators Australia Essay Competition are now open.

This initiative aligns with Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (Ciarb) extensive professional development specifically for young people, students, and early-career professionals.


The winning author of the competition will receive free registration for the Ciarb Australia Introduction to International Arbitration course and CPD event, along with a cash prize of $500. Additionally, the winning essay will be published on all Ciarb Australia platforms.

This year’s topic has been prepared by Angelina GomezCiarb Australia Councillor, Counsel, Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan

 

Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Arbitration

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is now ubiquitous in our everyday lives. The CSIRO describes AI as “maths, not magic”. It is technology that uses algorithms to imitate human thinking, our problem-solving abilities, and includes machine learning. Machine learning allows computers to “automatically” learn and develop, and deep learning models can create original content through the use of algorithm models to “see” patterns in data to make predictions.

With the expansion of AI-assisted technologies, there are opportunities for AI to assist in the facilitating and conducting of arbitrations. While taking advantage of these opportunities, we also need to be alert for issues with using AI in arbitration.

CIArb has prepared a guideline on the use of AI in arbitration:
https://www.ciarb.org/media/bpndtcgu/guideline-on-the-use-of-ai-in-arbitration_updated-sept-2025.pdf
This guideline also discusses the benefits and risks of using AI.

Taking this into account, discuss:

  1. Whether AI can be used to automate certain types of arbitration or parts of the arbitration process, to make it more accessible to a wider group by making it more affordable, what are the risks in doing so, and what mechanisms could be adopted to mitigate these risks; and
  2. Whether the enforceability of an arbitral award can be challenged if AI is used during the arbitration, or by the arbitrator, and what mechanisms could be adopted to mitigate these risks.

You may wish to consider:

  • Using AI to predict award outcomes
  • Using AI to predict opposition submissions
  • Using AI to predict enforcement issues in various jurisdictions (and how sympathetic local courts will be)
  • Using AI to predict an arbitrator’s likely bias
  • Ethical and bias considerations in AI
 

Submissions are invited from students studying a Bachelor, Juris Doctor or Masters level law degree at the date the entry is submitted. The competition is also open to lawyers in their first five years of practice, who may be members and non-members of Ciarb

All entries must be typed in a Word or text-searchable PDF document and clearly identified, including the author’s name, contact details and university/employer.

Each entry must be sent by email to Gianna Totaro, Chief Executive Officer, Ciarb Australia at info@ciarb.net.au by Friday, 30 October.

The winning essay will be chosen by an independent judging panel.

Competition stipulations:

  • Entries must not exceed 3,500 words (including footnotes)
  • Entries must be the original and sole work of the entrant
  • All entries will be acknowledged but will not be returned and the organisers will accept no responsibility for the safekeeping of essays
  • All entries will be anonymised before submission to the judging panel
  • CIArb Australia reserves the right to publish any part of any essay submitted for the competition.

 

Evaluation Criteria

Assessment Criteria 
Originality of ArgumentThe argument of the essay is to be original and innovative. The subject matter should be interesting and engaging. The essay should be persuasively argued throughout.
Quality of Knowledge and AnalysisThe essay is to be convincing, substantiated and understandable. Contrary arguments should be anticipated and a good critical evaluation of materials must be demonstrated.
Quality and Depth of ResearchThe essay should be thoroughly researched and make effective use of resource materials. The selection and use of relevant sources in support of an argument should demonstrate a high level of investigation.
Quality of Structure and WritingThe essay should display a close attention to style and presentation. A clear and logical structure is to be used with precise and concise writing.

 

All Enquiries

For further information, please contact:
Gianna Totaro
Chief Executive Officer, Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (Australia) Limited
Email: info@ciarb.net.au

We have a winner!

Congratulations to Paivi Adeniyi, Solicitor, DLA Piper Australia, Brisbane, winner of the 2025 Ciarb Australia Essay Competition.

Paivi has won a place at the next Introduction To International Arbitration course to be delivered on 10 September 2025.

Paivi Adeniyi

Ciarb Australia Essay Topic

This year’s topic has been prepared by Dr Drossos Stamboulakis, Ciarb Fellow, Barrister and Senior Lecturer, Monash University.

Recent case law has considered the issue of arbitrability from a range of perspectives, exploring the boundary between a jurisdiction by consent of the parties, and the intersection with public policy or sovereign power.

For example:

Discuss.

You may wish to consider, for example, divergent rationales explored in the judgments referred to above, divergences across jurisdictions, or whether there are (or should be) any broader principles, guidance or standards that apply in relation to arbitrability, party autonomy, or otherwise.
 

Ciarb Australia Essay Winner:  Paivi Adeniyi, Solicitor, DLA Piper Australia, Brisbane

Winning Entry: Party Autonomy and the Limits of Arbitrability: A Stoppable Force Meets an Immoveable Object

Ciarb Australia Essay Judge: Dr Drossos Stamboulakis, Ciarb Fellow, Barrister and Senior Lecturer, Monash University

Judge’s Comments: View here

 

We will soon be launching the 2026 Ciarb Australia Essay Competition.

 

All Enquiries

For further information, please contact:
Gianna Totaro
Chief Executive Officer, Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (Australia) Limited
Email: info@ciarb.net.au